Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Gail Brown's avatar

Hey Roger - your whole viewpoint & perspective intrigue me…

I will need to read & re-read this post and some other (previous) posts - maybe more than once???

The cognitive and learning processes you describe seem quite familiar to me (from a VERY different perspective!)???

Except - I view these differently and use different terms to describe what I think are the same / or similar processes…

Maybe this might not make sense to you now - as your way of describing and labelling these cognitive & learning processes is TOTALLY new to me?!?!

My doctoral research started with understanding “matching” processes for teaching complex concepts (more than 20 years ago) - THAT seems to be the ONLY label we have “in common”?

I think (from this first reading?!) I would probably use terms /labels like “transfer” & “generalisation” to describe similar processes to what you outline here?

My doctoral research had the goal of teaching students to “learn how to learn” - and I was able to make visible - the cognitive processes for how to answer questions about a text that students read?

I succeeded in the doctoral research in Grade 5 in Australia 🇦🇺 & teachers who used these materials reported anecdotally that these materials “taught them how to teach more effectively”! My statistically significant results were then replicated in schools - without me there - if teachers taught these in similar ways (now called “dosage”?) to what happened in my research…

And I generalised these materials - extending the strategy instruction and teaching examples for Grade 2 to Grade 6 in Australia 🇦🇺… My Postgrad students in Special Education taught these with success with students with special needs in Grades 7-10!

So - from a VERY different background and perspective- I am NOW reading your work and trying to make it all fit and extend my own knowledge???

Sorry, in advance, for this long reply - and hope this makes some sense to you???

Best always Gail 👍👍😊

1 more comment...

No posts

Ready for more?